by Peter Löcke //
You wake up at night to a loud bang. Still half asleep, still in a vague dream world, you look out of your bedroom window because you want to know where the deafening noise came from. You see that your neighbors' lights are also going on, but after a while they go out again. So you are not the only one who heard the loud bang. You shrug your shoulders, shake yourself briefly and go back to bed. The next day, nobody in the village talks about the night-time incident. No talk among neighbors, no conversation at the bakery. For whatever reason. Are you the first to mention it? Probably not. There is suddenly a huge hole, a crater, in the village. Strangely enough, people walk around this hole in silence and as if it were a matter of course. They will then probably also do it in silence. Like everyone else. Your local newspaper doesn't even mention the bang, and the large hole is initially concealed, then described in small print as a bump in the town center. You see the deep hole with your own eyes and yet you only see a small dent. You heard the bang with your own ears. Yet you don't remember it at all. I promise. At some point, you no longer believe your own eyes and ears. Why? Because you too will shut it up like everyone else. Because only language creates reality. Or do you want to be one of five weirdos in town who wants to talk about it? You don't want to. I'm rambling? Maybe you do.
I'll ramble on by claiming that the phenomenon also works in reverse. Whether it's in a conversation at the bakery, gossiping with a neighbor or on a continuous loop on the front page of your local newspaper, an invisible danger is being discussed. For whatever reason. You yourself have never seen, heard, tasted, smelled or sensually perceived this danger. You also don't know anyone personally who feels this way. Nevertheless, at some point you will also believe in this danger. Regardless of how big, small or non-existent this danger is. Or do you want to be one of five weirdos in town who denies the problem? Everyone is talking about it. So it must be true.
I would like to reproduce two statements and superimpose them. The first is from Ralph Brinkhaus. In a speech in the Bundestag, he thanked the media for "supporting" him with many touching stories about Covid. Supported? Supported who and with what? To save and protect lives. That was his ambition, his motivation for entering politics, said Brinkhaus afterwards, full of self-praise and pathos. For reasons of politeness, I would like to keep to myself what I think this performance says about the media and Brinkhaus. On the other hand, there was a remarkable response from the Sociologist Prof. Heinzlmaier in response to a question from Markus Langemann. Here in this channel. The question was why his youth study, which shows the mistrust and extent of suffering among younger people as a result of government measures, hardly ever reaches the public? Heinzlmaier's answer: because politicians know and are afraid that language creates reality. That's the truth. Language creates reality. And language can also prevent reality by keeping things quiet. Still nonsense?
Would you like to join me on another theoretical journey of thought? In the coming week, you will read nothing about incidence and death figures. No rising curves, no imminent overloading of the healthcare system. No pictures of intensive care units. No touching story of a C-list celebrity suffering from long covid. No scare scenarios based on a study. Neither on TV, nor on the radio, nor in the newspapers, nor when you open your email page or a new tab. Instead, you see images and reports in a theme week and in a continuous loop that show the extent of the suffering caused by government measures. On Monday, you will see overcrowded youth psychiatric wards, destroyed children's souls, reports on the psychological consequences of wearing masks and the rise in suicides. Exponentially increasing. Tuesday is dedicated to the economic and social consequences for an entire society for years to come. Destroyed livelihoods, destroyed businesses, unemployment and hopelessness. And it is dedicated to the rat's tail of human suffering. Domestic violence, alcoholism, loss of home or property, depression and much more. Wednesday focuses on the small matter of the abolition of fundamental rights and freedoms and the division of an entire society. I am fast-forwarding to Sunday, because seven days alone would not be enough for all the consequences of the measures anyway. On Sunday, every newspaper and every TV channel will cover the consequences for the so-called vulnerable groups. In other words, those who were supposedly to be protected. Carers for the elderly and old people are shown and heard talking about what loneliness and social deprivation do to people. It shows how retirement homes, which are actually residential homes, have been turned into sterile clinics by government measures. An 87-year-old broken man is shown in close-up, tearfully saying "I'm in the post-game period of my life. I want to fill the rest of my time with life. Stop it. Stop it at last."
What would the conversations at the bakery be like? What would the mood in society be like? And would Ralph Brinkhaus thank the media for their coverage? I doubt it. Maybe I'm one of five weirdos in town and a swearer. A person who hasn't heard the bang. That's exactly my problem. I have heard it. And I know that language creates reality.
Articles identified by name do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the publisher.

15 Responses
I would also like to quote Gerhard Roth: "Language is a socially mediated faculty and does not primarily serve the exchange of knowledge and the communication of insight, but rather the legitimization of predominantly unconsciously controlled behaviour in front of ourselves and others. This is an important fact of individual emotional survival and social coexistence." In "Feeling, Thinking, Acting", Suhrkamp 2001
We continue to lick our wounds academically, while leading politicians, as recently in Austria for example, claim that vaccinations are effective and safe, as studies "clearly prove"...
This is the reality that affects us.
That's exactly how it is.
At the latest since several daily newspapers wrote on August 1 last year that a demonstration in Berlin "had been broken up with several thousand participants", while at the same time tens of thousands of people were still happily marching through the streets of Berlin - on this day at the latest I had to bury my last illusions about a "free press". And the press could only become like that because people are apparently making it more and more their life's work to "not get into trouble".
Thank you very much for your great work.
I am so glad that more and more people have heard the bang and are talking about it.....
Great commentary - both in terms of content and style. Keep it up and thank you for your work.
................LEIDER...IST...ES...SO...LEIDER........................punkt..............................
By speaking, information is transported - always.
And the person who shouts the loudest and most is ultimately the one whose information is disseminated the furthest and whose information can therefore claim to be truthful. The truth, meaning, usefulness or even the entertainment value of the information being shouted out are completely irrelevant. Only all other thoughts must be shouted down.
The goal is that ultimately only my one true truth remains as a permitted thought. - Goal almost achieved.
I also heard the bang and I find it frightening that so many people didn't hear it, unfortunately also in my personal environment.
That's not quite right: the ego in combination with the language in our heads creates realities! When we are at peace within ourselves, it doesn't matter whether there has been a bang at all or which religious majority (minority) I (don't) want to belong to. There is an immense treasure trove of life on our earth that manages without language 🙂
"There is an immense treasure trove of life on our planet that manages entirely without language."
Nice sentence. I absolutely agree with you, Mr. Günzel. A dog usually has little fear of corona and the climate crisis. But humans do.
When I was young, I was fascinated by the philosophy of language. It still fascinates me today. Thank goodness I had a great teacher. To introduce us to Wittgenstein ("The limits of my language are the limits of my world") and co, she told an anecdote about Christian missionaries who came across a remote primitive people deep in the jungle. The people there lived a polygamous life. Ownership itself was completely alien to them. This, in turn, naturally alienated the missionaries. Once they had familiarized themselves with the limited vocabulary of the indigenous people, they discovered that there were no possessive pronouns in this foreign language. No mine, yours, ours. No concept - no comprehension. The primitive people could neither understand nor feel what these missionaries wanted from them. And the missionaries lacked the linguistic tools to communicate.
Years ago, I was allowed to take part in a five-day Buddhist seminar. During this time, there was - among other restrictions - a ban on speaking. That was an incredibly intense experience for me. Contact between people without language is so much more concrete. I think those who see language as an art form of communication are not so easily impressed by the 'noise' of the general public 🙂
Many have heard the bang, but most people lack the courage to talk about it.
There are now so many craters in the village that it takes a great deal of mental effort for people with sight to stay on their path. How can we close these holes in the ground in time before too many of our fellow human beings stumble into them and are lost?
I hear and hear and hear it, and in fact no one wants to talk to me about it. But I'm no longer young and strong enough to fight, unfortunately. However, I still have the opportunity to encourage and support those who do, or, as in your case, to let a little light flutter from time to time to support the fight of the younger, stronger ones. AND TO THANK THEM FOR IT!
I HAVE ALSO HEARD THE BANG - and I haven't been able to get it out of my mind for a year and a half...